17 Old South Road • $4,250,000 Pending
Mid Island, Nantucket, MA 02554
Exceptional commercial opportunity on one of Nantucket’s busiest corridors. Currently home to Fusaro’s Homemade Italian Restaurant, this versatile building offers 1,558 sq. ft. on the main level plus a full, high-ceiling basement for prep, storage, and refrigeration, plus a 780 sq. ft. covered patio for 3-season use. Total usable space is almost 4,000 sq. ft. Additional expansion is possible. The kitchen is on the first floor. The property includes an asphalt parking lot with 20 parking spaces and additional parking on nearby Town property. Located in the CN (Commercial Neighborhood) zoning district, it allows a wide range of uses—residential, retail, wellness, or food service—with further potential by Special Permit. An outstanding investment opportunity—impossible to duplicate under current building codes and land constraints. Business—including FF&E, goodwill, name, logo, and recipes—available separately.
Floor 1: The reception area includes a 10-seat bar on the left and a 4-seat high-top table. The dining room comfortable inside seating and the covered, heated patio is perfect for three-season use. The kitchen is on this floor.
Floor 2: None
Floor 3: None
Basement: Full basement includes a prep area and equipment that supports the restaurant and bar. There are two employee half baths, plus locked rooms for liquor storage and an office.
Parking: 20 plus parking on nearby Town property.
Listed by Fisher Real Estate
Virtual Tour
17 Old South Road Location
Contact Agent
xProperty Information for 17 Old South Road
Property Summary
Type: Commercial
Rooms: 6
Year Built: 1996
Remodeled: 2012
Water View:
Other View:
Zoning: CN
Lot Size(SF): 1558
Furnished: Partially
2nd Dwelling: None
Water: Town
Sewer: Twn
Lot Size(A): 0.34
Beds/Baths: 0/0
Wtr Frontage:
Total SqFt(GLA): 14810
Amenities
First Floor Bedrooms: 0
Heating: GFHA
Fireplaces: 0
Floors: Wood, carpet, tile, concrete.
Yard: Front
Parking: 20 plus parking on nearby Town property.
Foundation: Poured
Lead Paint:
Recreation and Outdoor Spaces: Patio
Amenities:
Taxes and Fees
Building Assessment: 671600
Land Assessment: 1217200
Total Assessment: 1888800
Tax Year: 2025
Property History for 17 Old South Road
$455,000
$430,000
$1,275,000
$1,275,000
$836,000
$836,000
Similar Houses
17 Old South Road • Mid Island • $4,250,000
0 beds | 0 baths | 14,810 sq ft
1 of 24
