11 Milk Street, Nantucket, MA

Originally built in 1761 in the old town of Sherburne, The Thomas Starbuck House found its new home at 11 Milk Street in 1790. 11 Milk Street is a beautifully restored Quaker-style home that blends historic charm with modern comforts. Ideally situated in a prime location, this turnkey residence offers four bedrooms, three full baths, and one-half bath. The light-filled kitchen is a true standout, featuring a wet bar, pantry, and ample storage—perfect for both everyday living and entertaining. Many of the home’s original details, including an inglenook fireplace and pine floors, have been thoughtfully preserved, creating a warm and inviting atmosphere. The outdoor space includes a private patio and parking space, making this historic gem as functional as it is charming.

First Floor: The entry hall is spacious and features an L-shaped staircase. The comfotable front parlor boasts antique paneling surrounding a functional fireplace. The large dining room also has an impressive antique inglenook fireplace. A hall with an original blanket/gun closet connects to the den, originally the Starbuck family's birthing room, which has served as a downstairs bedroom with a working fireplace and powder room, as well as a Dutch door that opens onto a large, private patio. To the rear of the home, the modern eat-in kitchen is generously sized, featuring a center island with a breakfast bar and a walk-in pantry. A rear staircase off the kitchen leads directly to the primary bedroom. A mudroom with laundry and great storage is at the back of the house.

Second Floor: The front stairway ascends to a spacious second-floor landing, currently utilized as office space. The front bedroom features a fireplace and a private bath. The middle bedroom also includes a fireplace and a large bathroom with a tub/shower. The primary bedroom at the rear of the home has cathedral ceilings and a generous bath with double vanities, a free-standing tub, and a shower, as well as a stairway leading to the attic.

Third Floor: Generous storage space.

Basement: A root cellar with both interior and exterior access is equipped with mechanical systems. The basement walls and chimney base have been completely rebuilt, with rigid insulation and a spotless appearance.

Parking: Yes

Listed by Great Point Properties