2 York Street, Nantucket, MA

Nestled in a quiet corner of Nantucket’s Historic District, 2 York Street offers a rare and captivating opportunity, just moments from the heart of downtown. This quintessential antique property features a 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom main house and a charming detached 1-bedroom, 1-bath studio—ideal for guests, extended family, or rental income. The main house sits on a 4,356± square foot lot, surrounded by mature gardens and tranquil yard, complete with a garden shed and off-street parking. Inside, you'll find original wide-plank pine floors, four fireplaces, and a lightly refreshed kitchen and bathrooms. The open-concept kitchen, dining, and living area is filled with natural light and offers a seamless flow for entertaining or relaxed everyday living. The living room features a sunny bay window and an original wood-burning fireplace, providing a cozy space to unwind. The first-floor bedroom serves as a versatile overflow den or guest area, offering additional room for relaxation or entertainment. Upstairs, two generously sized bedrooms—one with a skylight and each with its own fireplace—offer antique charm and ambiance and share a spacious, well-appointed bath. Subdivision Potential This property may qualify for a potential 81L subdivision, offering the possibility to create two conforming lots (subject to approval). A rare chance to expand or reimagine this delightful home. A true Nantucket gem, rich in history and full of potential. Just blocks from Main Street, Great Harbor Yacht Club, the harbor, and the island’s renowned beaches, this home combines antique charm with modern possibilities—ready for you to make it your own. .

First Floor: The first floor of the main house offers a warm and inviting layout that blends traditional Nantucket charm with comfortable, functional living spaces. Upon entry, you're welcomed into a charming foyer with original wide-plank pine floors and classic moldings. To the left, the bright and airy living room features a sunny bay window, wood-burning fireplace, and abundant natural light—an ideal space for gathering or relaxing after a day at the beach. A graceful, antique staircase rises from the entryway to the second floor, adding character and charm. Just beyond, a hallway leads you into the open-concept kitchen and dining area, where modern updates blend seamlessly with historic details. The kitchen includes tile countertops, ample cabinetry, and quality appliances—perfect for everyday cooking or entertaining.

To the left of the kitchen is an en-suite bedroom, complete with a full bath. This convenient main-level bedroom provides flexibility for guests, multigenerational living, or single-level lifestyle options.

Second Floor: The second-floor features two well-appointed bedrooms and a shared full bathroom, creating a peaceful and private retreat above the main living areas. Both bedrooms offer charming architectural details, including pitched ceilings, wood flooring, and fireplaces as decor and charm. Each room provides ample space for queen or twin beds, with closet storage and space for additional furnishings. The centrally located full bath is conveniently accessible from both bedrooms and features classic tile and updated fixtures. Perfect for family and guests, the second-floor balances cozy character with comfortable livability —just one of the many thoughtful touches throughout this in-town gem.

Basement: full unfinished

Second Dwelling: Tucked away behind the main residence, this enchanting 1-bedroom, 1-bath studio cottage offers a serene and private escape in the heart of Nantucket ’s Historic District. Brimming with character and thoughtfully designed for comfort and flexibility, the space lends itself beautifully to a variety of uses—whether as a guest house, artist’s studio, remote workspace, or income-generating rental. A newly installed stack washer and dryer, conve niently located in the adjacent shed, serves both the studio and provides overflow laundry capacity for the main house. A rare find in such a coveted location, this hidden gem seamlessly blends historic charm with modern convenience, all just moments from the shops, restaurants, and timeless allure of downtown Nantucket.

Parking: yes

Listed by William Raveis Nantucket