Nantucket Real Estate News May 11, 2026

Nantucket Real Estate Updates

Town Meeting

Town Meeting has come and gone. The main hot topics were 1) whether or not to support the building of a new Our Island Home at an estimated cost of $137mm, 2) whether or not to support the Nantucket Public Schools' proposal to renovate the athletic facilities and change the Vito Capizzo field from grass to turf at an estimated cost of $26mm, 3) whether or not to expand the municipal sewer system at an estimated cost of $45mm, and 4) whether to approve allowing for the expansion of the erosion control geotube project at the base of the Baxter Road bluff, to be funded privately. All were approved to be on the ballot for a vote except the one that was going to be funded privately. Should be interesting to see which way people vote at the ballot when their heartstrings aren't getting pulled as they do at Town Meeting. $208mm is a lot of money...

Market's still moving.

Creative Solutions

With summer just around the corner, the Island is coming to life, and so is the real estate market. In a market this active, keeping an open mind is key.

Team JPFCO recently worked with two clients, a Buyer and a Seller, on a creative deal that made it happen for both sides. The Buyer was stretched thin on the property they wanted to purchase because they also had a property of their own to sell. The challenge: they weren't planning to list their property until July, when their selling season begins, but they wanted to close on a Nantucket home in June.

To bridge the gap, Team JPFCO structured a plan where the Buyer would pay the Seller three times the monthly rental rate, with those payments credited back to the Buyer at closing. If the Buyer didn't close within six months, the Seller would keep the inflated rental income and move on to the next offer. A win all around: immediate cash flow for the Seller, and the time the Buyer needed to make it work.

Looking forward to a fun summer of making it happen.

Quintessential Nantucket

Some of the best parts of Nantucket are the ones you stumble into by accident, and some are worth seeking out on purpose. We've pulled together a list of our favorite ways to spend a day on the island, from the iconic to the under-the-radar. Whether you're visiting for the first time or have been coming for decades, we hope you find something on here to add to your summer.

Sunset at Millie's. Sip a margarita, dig into Baja-style eats, and watch the sky melt into pink and gold over the dunes. The quintessential Nantucket evening.
Bike to Sankaty Head. Pedal out to the red-and-white striped beacon perched on the bluffs at the easternmost point of the island. Then roll into 'Sconset Village for a sandwich at Claudette's, and finish with a stroll along the Bluff Walk, where rose-covered cottages spill toward the Atlantic.
Ice cream at The Juice Bar. Brave the line and try one of their signature flavors in a fresh-baked waffle cone. Crantucket, Cookie Butt (IYKYK), Green Monster, and The Carl are all local favorites.
Wander Coskata-Coatue. Lace up your sneakers and explore the wildlife refuge, where miles of trails wind through dunes, woods, and beachfront, offering one of the most beautiful (and peaceful) ways to take in the island's wild side.
Shop downtown. Wander the cobblestone streets and pop into the local boutiques, galleries, and shops. Browse Erica Wilson for a charming needlepoint project, hunt for a one-of-a-kind find at the antique shops, and stop by Lemon Press for an iced Tahini Date Latte (tastes like a cookie in a cup) before continuing your wander.
Go whale watching. Set sail on an excursion with one of the outfitters offering tours throughout the season. Book one that fits your schedule and prepare to be awed when a humpback breaches off the bow.
Pick your own at Bartlett's Farm. Spend an afternoon gathering veggies, strawberries, or flowers straight from the fields. A sweet outing that ends with a basket full of summer.
Stargaze at Maria Mitchell. Spend an evening at the Loines Observatory peering through state-of-the-art telescopes, a fitting tribute to Nantucket's pioneering astronomer and America's first female professional astronomer.
Rent a SUP board and glide across Nantucket Harbor. Paddle past moored sailboats, spot seabirds along the shore, and take in the island from a perspective most visitors miss.
Morning buns at Wicked Island Bakery. Wake up early and chase a warm one before they sell out. Flaky, buttery, and so beloved they often disappear before noon.
Climb Altar Rock. Bike or drive to one of the highest points on the island. Take in sweeping views of moorland, ponds, and ocean, and keep an eye out for arrowheads underfoot, a quiet reminder of Nantucket's earliest inhabitants.
Beach clambake from Sayle's. Order the whole spread and unpack it on the sand. Lobster, steamers, corn, and chowder, no reservation required.
Afternoon at Cisco Brewery. Order a beer flight, settle in for live music, and graze your way through the food trucks parked outside.
Walk through history. Join a tour with the Nantucket Historical Association and step back in time. Knowledgeable guides bring the island's whaling-era streets to life, weaving stories of sea captains, abolitionists, and the families who shaped Nantucket into what it is today.
Ghost Walk after dark. As darkness settles over the cobblestones, take a guided tour through the shadowy corners of Town. Hear the lingering tales of sea captains lost at sea, restless widows, and the haunted houses they're said to still occupy.

10 Silver Street | $6,995,000 | Town

Tucked into the heart of Nantucket's coveted Old Historic District, just moments from Main Street, this exceptional newly built compound blends timeless architecture with refined, modern living, boasting over 5,200 sf of living space. Designed with a sense of "modern classic" elegance, the property offers a beautifully crafted five-bedroom main residence complemented by a separate three-bedroom guest house, ideal for extended family, guests, or flexible use. Both homes feature thoughtfully designed open floor plans, where light-filled interiors flow effortlessly from one space to the next. Clean lines, high-end finishes, beautiful trim details throughout, and understated coastal sophistication define the aesthetic, creating an inviting yet elevated atmosphere. Living and dining areas seamlessly connect to well-appointed kitchens, perfect for both everyday living and entertaining.

The outdoor space features a front yard, a covered porch for al fresco dining off the main house, a private fire pit area surrounded by seating, and a stone patio with a grill area and covered porch off the guest house. There are two off-street parking spots. The setting offers the best of both worlds: peaceful residential charm paired with immediate access to the island's shops, restaurants, and harbor just steps away. A rare opportunity to own a newly constructed, turnkey compound in one of Nantucket's most desirable locations. Sold furnished.

Click the link below to view additional photos, property details, and the full listing on our website.

10 Silver Street | JPFCO →