258 Polpis Road • $16,850,000

Polpis, Nantucket, MA

Search

“Harbor Creek’ is one of the finest Polpis estates that exists. This private and stunning property on just over 4 acres and across the way from acres of protected conservation land includes a five bedroom main house and a two bedroom guest house, room for a pool, direct harbor access as well as outstanding panoramic views and beyond. Renovated by Cross Rip Builders and decorated to perfection, this custom built home includes an outstanding ‘chef’s kitchen’, two separate bright and open living rooms each with a fireplace, antique details and a large primary bedroom with a private deck looking out towards the harbor. There are three sets of French doors leading to the rear deck making for easy access to the lush and flowing expansive yard; perfect for sunset cocktails, entertaining and family gatherings as well as direct access to your own boat! There is a separate two bedroom guest house and mature, beautiful landscaping surrounding the entire property providing much privacy. Whether you are looking for the ideal summer retreat or want to enjoy all of the island seasons, look no further than this exquisite and sophisticated one of a kind property. This is an opportunity to own one of the most iconic properties on Nantucket, also known as the house with the white dory in the front yard; a true island landmark!

258 Polpis Road Location
Property Code: #91914
Sold Date:
Oct 15, 2025
Asking Price:
$18,795,000
Original Price:
$20,000,000
Bedrooms:
7 beds
Bathrooms:
6 and 1 half
Lot:
174,240 sq ft
Year Built:
1920
Heating Type:
GFHA
Listed:
196 ago
Assessed Value:
$10,117,300
Comparable Sales to this Property
56 Monomoy Road Monomoy
$18,400,000
56 Monomoy Road Monomoy
7 Beds
6+ Baths
DOM: 63
30 Easton Street Brant Point
$18,200,000
30 Easton Street Brant Point
6 Beds
4 Baths
DOM: 254
11 Hinckley Lane Cliff
$18,000,000
11 Hinckley Lane Cliff
6 Beds
6 Baths
DOM: 0
9 Lincoln Avenue Cliff
$17,995,000
9 Lincoln Avenue Cliff
10 Beds
8+ Baths
DOM: 88
218 Cliff Road Cliff
$17,995,000
218 Cliff Road Cliff
7 Beds
7+ Baths
DOM: 126
33 Pocomo Road Pocomo
$17,995,000
33 Pocomo Road Pocomo
8 Beds
6 Baths
DOM: 34
141 Cliff Road Cliff
$17,950,000
141 Cliff Road Cliff
5 Beds
5+ Baths
DOM: 93
5 Cudweed Road Cisco
$17,825,000
5 Cudweed Road Cisco
5 Beds
4 Baths
DOM: 179
143 Wauwinet Road Wauwinet
$17,775,000
143 Wauwinet Road Wauwinet
5 Beds
6 Baths
DOM: 26
13 Washing Pond Road Cliff
$17,750,000
13 Washing Pond Road Cliff
7 Beds
8 Baths
DOM: 36
7  Heather Lane Cliff
$18,875,000
7 Heather Lane Cliff
0 Beds
0 Baths
DOM: 0
33 & 35 Shell Street Sconset
$18,875,000
33 & 35 Shell Street Sconset
16 Beds
9 Baths
DOM: 208
1, 3, & 3A Reeds Way Tom Nevers
$18,990,000
1, 3, & 3a Reeds Way Tom Nevers
15 Beds
11 Baths
DOM: 368
4 Shawkemo Hills Lane & 2 Wingspread Lane Shawkemo
$19,400,000
4 Shawkemo Hills... Shawkemo
8 Beds
6 Baths
DOM: 222
77 Eel Point Road Dionis
$19,580,000
77 Eel Point Road Dionis
7 Beds
8+ Baths
DOM: 0
36 Washing Pond Road Cliff
$19,950,000
36 Washing Pond Road Cliff
0 Beds
0 Baths
DOM: 48
30 Eel Point Road Dionis
$19,950,000
30 Eel Point Road Dionis
6 Beds
6 Baths
DOM: 21
25 Lincoln Avenue Cliff
$19,995,000
25 Lincoln Avenue Cliff
7 Beds
9+ Baths
DOM: 826
256 Polpis Road Polpis
$19,995,000
256 Polpis Road Polpis
8 Beds
5 Baths
DOM: 470
51 Squam Road Squam
$20,000,000
51 Squam Road Squam
8 Beds
11+ Baths
DOM: 0
Back to top